ball mills versus rod mills

difference between rod mill and ball mill

difference between rod mill and ball mill [randpic] What are the differences between ball mill and rod mill The rod of diameter from 50 to 100 mm is often used as the grinding medium, and the filling rate of rod mill is 35% to 45%, while filling rate of ball mill is 40% to 50%. Rod i

Ball Mills - Mineral Processing & Metallurgy

Ball VS Rod Mill Conversion The correct grinding mill depends so much upon the particular ore being treated and the product desired, that a mill must have maximum flexibility in length, type of grinding medium, type of discharge, and speed.

Differences And Similarities Between Rod Mills And Ball ...

The grinding fineness of the ball mill is finer, usually the output particle size is between 0.074-0.4mm, while the output fineness of the rod mill is between 0.833-0.147mm. 4.Classification is different. Ball mills can be divided into overflow-type and lattice-type ball mills, while rod mills are classified into overflow-type and open-type rod ...

Key considerations when selecting a mill lining system

Figure 1: Sliding-abrasion action in a Ball Mill. Figure 2: Cascading-impact action in a SAG mill. Rubber and composite mill lining systems. In the past, grinding mills were typically lined with cast metal linings of varying steel or iron alloys, and lining system selection was typically driven by level of wear protection and cost.

Ball Mill VS AG Mill: What are the Similarities and ...

Ball mill, rod mill and AG mill are common equipment for grinding operation in mineral processing plants. The difference between ball mill and rod mill has been known before, but what are the similarities and differences between ball mill and AG mill? This article will take you to explore so as to help you choose the appropriate grinding equipment more …

Rod Tube And Ball Mills Comparison-ball Mill

Ball Mill Vs Rod Mill How To Choose Ball Mill Or Rod. The rod mill usually uses 50100mm diameter steel rod as grinding medium while the ball mill uses steel ball as grinding medium the length of steel rod is 2550mm shorter than the cylinder and it is usually made of high carbon steel with carbon content of 08 1 the loading capacity of rod is about 35 45 of the effective volume

Ball Mill Explained - saVRee

Ball mills with a drum length to diameter ratio greater than 1.5 are referred to as tube mills. Ball mills may be primary or secondary grinders. Primary grinders are fed from crushers such as a jaw crusher. Secondary grinders are fed from other grinders e.g. a rod mill. Ball mills are usually either of the grate (diaphragm) or overflow type.

Rod Tube And Ball Mills Comparison

Rod Tube And Ball Mills Comparison. 8.3.2.2 ball mills. the ball mill is a tumbling mill that uses steel balls as the grinding media. the length of the cylindrical shell is usually 1–1.5 times the shell diameter ( figure 8.11). the feed can be dry, with less than 3% moisture to minimize ball coating, or slurry containing 20–40% water by weight..

THE MODE OF BALL MILL OPERATION

This is the most common mode used during operation of rod mills, ball mills with central unloading and pipe mills in the case of wet and dry grinding of non-corrosive materials. Mixed operating mode is illustrated in the figure b, where the dotted line shows the position of the grinding balls in flight along the trajectory and solid lines ...

advantages and disadvantages of rod mill

advantages of using rod mill whitehillstree. advantages and disadvantages of ball mill Ball mills and rod mills are both excellent mining machines for grinding ores into fine powders and particles However there are some advantages to using rod Contact US Rod Mills 911 Metallurgist Jan 25 2018 The Steel Head Rod Mill is available with five types of discharge cost advantages

What's the Difference Between Ball Mill, Rod Mill and SAG ...

In the order you have listed; a ball mill can fine grind down to <400 mesh if needed, a rod mill will efficiently grind to 150/200 mesh range, and a roll mill can do a +/- 100 mesh. The ball and rod mills are similar in appearence, as a large rotating lined cylindrical tube filled with either metal balls or long rods used as the grinding medium.

Rod Mills Comparable

Rod mills are very similar to ball mills, except they use long rods for grinding media. The rods grind the ore by tumbling within the the mill, similar to the grinding balls in a ball mill. To prevent the conditions leading to rod charge tangling, the length to diameter ratio is maintained at 1.4 to 1.6.

Difference Between Sag Mill vs Ball Mill - mech4study

BALL MILL. 1. SAG mill is the primary tool for grinding. SAG mill is used before the other mills. Ball mill is a secondary, and it is used after the SAG mill. 2. SAG mill breaks the raw material into pieces for the further grinding. Ball mill is used to grind the pieces of raw material into. powder-like structures.

Grinding Mills and Their Types – IspatGuru

Ball mills. Ball mill (Fig 1) is same kind of mill as rod mill, except that it is filled with balls instead of rods. Because of balls have greater ratio of surface area than rods they are more suitable for fine grinding. Balls are also lighter, so the kinetic energy of a single dropping ball is smaller than a rod.

Comparing Used Ball Mills Vs Used Rod Mills

Ball mills and rod mills are both excellent mining machines for grinding ores into fine powders and particles. However there are some advantages to using rod mills rather than ball mills for larger mining projects including greater efficiency, better grinding performance and …

What Is a Ball Mill? - Monroe EngineeringMonroe Engineering

For a ball mill to work, critical speed must be achieved. Critical speed refers to the speed at which the enclosed balls begin to rotate along the inner walls of the ball mill. If a ball mill fails to reach critical speed, the balls will remain stationary at the bottom where they have little or no impact on the material. Ball Mills vs ...

what is the difference between vertical mill ball mill ...

What is the definition of vertical mill? – Online Training …. Distinguish between a vertical and horizontal mill. …. The difference between a measurement reading … threaded device with reciprocating ball bearings that rotates ….

How HPGRs compare to conventional milling

Grinding ratio can reach 4000 ~ 5000, more than ten times higher than ball, rod mill. Application Autogenous mills are common in the primary processing unit for the major large grinding circuits in the mining field, separates out some precious metals, like …

7 Major Differences between Ball Mill and Rod Mill-SBM ...

3. Different grinding medium. The Rod mill usually uses the steel rod with a diameter of 50-100mm as the grinding medium, while the ball mill usually uses the steel ball as the grinding medium. The steel balls of ball mill are in point contact, while the steel rods of Rod mill are in linear contact, so their working ways are obviously different.

A Method of C alculating Autogenous/ Semi-Autogenous ...

No 1 rod mill/ball mill circuit was operating very effi ciently when comparing the combined operating work indices for both mills with the rod mill and ball mill laboratory work indices. Note, in Figure. 1, that the rod mill product slope is less than 0.5 due to an extra amount of nes present being fi fi ner than 650 μm.

Ball Mills vs Rod Mills

These terms must not be confused with differential grinding, which has to do with the relative grinding rates of two or more minerals in an ore. Rod Mills = Selective Grinding Ball Mills = Non-Selective Grinding Large Balls & Small Rods Compared Is it better to use a grinding mill with large balls or will small rods?

difference between ball mill and sand mill

Difference Between Rod Mill And Ball Mill. Difference Between Rod Mill And Ball Mill Figure 82 media motion in the tumbling mill81 grinding 811 grinding action industrial grinding machines used in the mineral processing industries are mostly of the tumbling mill mills exist in a variety of types rod ball pebble autogenous and grinding action is ...

What is Ball Mill | How Many Types of Ball Mills | M&C

1. Ball Mill: The grinding medium is mainly short steel bar or steel ball.The grinding force of ball mill is large, the structure is light, and the rotation speed is stable. 2. Rod Mill: The grinding medium is mainly steel rod, the diameter of steel rod is mostly between 50-100mm, and the grinding time is longer.. 3. Gravel Mill: The grinding medium mainly includes pebble, gravel, …

Mill (grinding) - Wikipedia

Rod mills are less common than ball mills for grinding minerals. The rods used in the mill, usually a high-carbon steel, can vary in both the length and the diameter. However, the smaller the rods, the larger is the total surface area and hence, the greater the grinding efficiency.

Ball Mill Loading - Dry Milling - Paul O. Abbe

The starting point for ball mill media and solids charging generally starts as follows: 50% media charge. Assuming 26% void space between spherical balls (non-spherical, irregularly shaped and mixed-size media will increase or decrease the free space) 50% x 26% = 13% free space. Add to this another 10%-15% above the ball charge for total of 23% ...

Differences And Similarities Between Rod Mills And Ball ...

Difference between rod mill and ball mill. 1.Grinding bodies work differently. We know that the rod mill is called a rod mill because its grinding medium is a steel rod, and the grinding medium of a ball mill is a steel ball. Due to the different shapes of the grinding bodies, their working methods also have their own characteristics.

Mill & Scrubber Linings Wear Resistant

taken to target enhanced availability of the Mill (reducing down time losses) with increased efficiency in grinding, and reduction in power drawn. Trelleborg has a wide range of Rubber lifter bars and plates for Ball Mills, Rod Mills and Drum Scrubbers. Trelleborg Standard Rubber Lifter sizes are as follows: • 210mm (W) x 250mm (H)